June 26, 2005
Most of the inmates
"have never eaten better…have never been treated better…courtesy of the
American taxpayer."
-- Duncan Hunter,
chairman of the US House Armed Services Committee, defending allegations
of mistreatment at Guantanamo Bay.
We
can add a new chapter to the Bush Administration’s war on free speech as
it was revealed yesterday that an Al Jazeera cameraman has been in custody
for three years at Guantanamo Bay. Al-Hajj, a Sudanese national, was
arrested in Afghanistan in 2001 and has remained in prison without being
charged for four years.
Is this what
Rumsfeld breezily refers to as the "worst of the worst"? If so,
independent journalists around the world should take note.
The report of Al-Haj’s
unlawful detention comes on the heels of a growing furor over eyewitness
accounts of torture at Gitmo and an outcry from human rights groups (and
members of Congress) to close down the facility.
Amnesty
International, who referred to the prison as "the gulag of our times," has
again been vindicated in its claims by these new charges that Al-Haj "has
suffered extreme physical, sexual and religious abuse," charges that are
consistent with other reports that the US is practicing "systematic" abuse
of detainees.
Attorney Clive
Stafford-Smith, who visited clients at Guantanamo two weeks ago, said,
"Sami Al-Hajj had been beaten by his interrogators…. He has been beaten.
He had a huge scar on his face when I saw him." (Al Jazeera)
"He is completely
innocent," said Stafford-Smith. "He is about as much of a terrorist as my
granddad. The only reason he has been treated like he has is because he is
an Aljazeera journalist. The Americans have tried to make him an informant
with the goal of getting him to say that Aljazeera is linked to al-Qaida."
Stafford-Smith’s claims seem more credible
given the open hostility of the Bush Administration, and particularly
Donald Rumsfeld, towards Al Jazeera. Rumsfeld ordered the bombing of Al
Jazeera’s news facilities in Kabul and Baghdad (even though the US
military had been given the facilities’ coordinates by Al Jazeera). In the
siege of Baghdad an F-16 launched a direct hit on the Al Jazeera station,
killing veteran journalist Tariq Ayoub, even though there was no
indication of fighting in the area. Many consider the attack to be a
"premeditated" act of murder.
Rumsfeld continued
his attack on Al Jazeera last week with a rambling harangue completely
divorced from the facts. At a security conference in Singapore he said,
"if anyone lived in the Middle East and watched a network like the
Aljazeera day after day after day, even if he was an American, he
would start waking up and asking what's wrong." "But America is not wrong.
It's the people who are going on television chopping off people's heads,
that is wrong," he said.
In fact, Al Jazeera has never broadcast
images of hostages being beheaded. The video of Nick Berg’s execution
appeared on an independent web site. But, by now, we know that the facts
are of little concern to Rumsfeld; what he wants is uniformity of opinion
and a narrative that reflects the positive aspects of America’s aggression
in Iraq. To that end, he has enlisted the support of America’s "embedded"
journalists and intentionally targets anyone who veers from the accepted
storyline. (Presently, at least 8 journalists are being detained by the US
in Iraq, some of whom, apparently, have stories and footage of Rumsfeld’s
Dresden-type destruction of Falluja)
Guantanamo’s Apologists
In the last week
Donald Rumsfeld and VP Dick Cheney have defended Guantanamo publicly
claiming it’s an indispensable part of the war on terror. General Richard
Meyers went as far to say that it was a "model facility"; an appraisal
that is strikingly at odds with the reports of torture and the
mistreatment of prisoners. Right-wing columnist Charles Krauthammer, a
dependable source for absurd commentary, noted that treatment of prisoners
at Guantanamo was "remarkably humane and tolerant." (This from a pundit
whose anti-Arab sentiments have deep roots and a long history) Neither
Cheney, Rumsfeld, Meyers nor Krauthammer addressed the numerous accounts
of prisoners "chained hand and foot in a fetal position to the floor, with
no chair, food or water. Most times they had urinated or defecated on
themselves and had been left there for 18, 24 hours or more." (FBI report,
quoted in Dissident Voice, January 11, 2005)
Never the less, the
debate over Guantanamo is not about to disappear anytime soon. Even
supporters of the war in Iraq, like Tom Friedman and Senator Joe Biden,
understand that the prison has been a public relations nightmare that has
emboldened America’s enemies and put American soldiers at greater risk.
In a June 21 article
in the New York Times, Anthony Lewis chronicles some of the
incidents of cruelty at Guantanamo and notes the violations to the Geneva
Conventions which prohibit "outrages upon personal dignity, in particular,
humiliating and degrading treatment." He also refers the less frequently
mentioned United Nations Convention against Torture which requires the US
to "prevent in any territory under its jurisdiction…. cruel, inhuman and
degrading treatment." The Bush Administration has painstakingly
constructed legal arguments that refute the applicability of both
conventions, strongly suggesting that they are willfully engaged in war
crimes.
To fully appreciate
the depravity of the Bush claque, we only need to visit the Rush Limbaugh
web site, where the drug-addicted spokesman for the administration is
currently hawking T-shirts (orange: "I got my free Koran and Prayer
Rug at G’itmo") and baseball caps (orange: "Camp G’itmo") in an public
relations scheme to trivialize the horrors of systematic torture of
detainees in US custody. Limbaugh has always been at the
forefront of apologists for the abuse of prisoners. During the Abu
Ghraib scandal he defended the conduct of the military by saying that
"they were just blowing off steam." Perhaps, Limbaugh finds something
uplifting about being "sodomized with a chemical light" or having
"electrodes attached to his penis to simulate electric torture," it’s
impossible to know. But, for most sane people, these are conspicuous acts
of barbarism for which the perpetrators must be held accountable.
Plan Gitmo
Despite widespread
condemnation, the Bush Administration will never abandon the Guantanamo
concentration camp. As Amnesty International’s Curt Goering puts it, the
administration "plans to memorialize in bricks and mortar its decision to
operate outside of the law." This is precisely the case. Guantanamo is
emblematic of a militarized world stripped of humanity or justice. It
looms as the salient icon of the new world order.
Mike Whitney
lives in Washington state, and can be reached at:
fergiewhitney@msn.com.
Other Articles by Mike
Whitney
*
The Bush
Radio Address: More Delusional Blather While Iraq Bleeds
* The
Friedman Solution: Reinstate the Draft
* Body
Slamming the 4th Amendment
* Operation
Desperation: Rumsfeld’s Baghdad Fiasco
* The EU
Constitution: Don’t Believe the BS
* Protecting
the Plutocrats
* What Was
Laura Bush Doing at the Al Aqsa Mosque?
* Free Jose
Padilla!
* Alberto
Gonzales’ Kristallnacht: Purges for a Safer America
* Tom
Friedman: The Imperial Chronicler
* Gods,
Gays, and George Bernard Shaw
* A
Tentative Strategy for Ending the War
* The
Specter of Violence in America
*
Free Speech
in the Crosshairs
* Why
America Needs to be Defeated in Iraq
* More
Madness at the Bush News Conference
*
Ratzinger’s Plan to Hide the Pedophiles
* Let’s Let
Atheists Back into Politics
* Pope
Ratzinger: More "Pie-in-the-Sky" for the Struggling Masses
* The
Purveyors of Violence: The NY Times in Falluja
* Screw You,
Paul Volker!
* Pope TV
and the New World Media
* The
Economic Tsunami: Sooner Than You Think
* Destroy
Abu Ghraib!
* Terri
Schiavo and the Battered Judiciary
*
Railroading Moussaoui
* The
Wolfowitz Appointment: A Red Flag for the Coming Wars
* "Economic
Meltdown" -- Sorry, but We’re Toast
* John
Bolton and the Road to Tehran
* Clearing
the Way for the American Police State
*
Challenging
the Language of Violence
* Jose
Padilla and the 10 Commandments
* Crushing
the UN for a Stronger America
* Europe to
Bush: "Hands Off Iran"?
* The
Incredible Shrinking Dollar
*
Assassinating Al-Hariri Fits Washington’s Plan
*
Washington’s Plan to Foment Civil War in Iraq
* Condi’s
Euro-Tour
* Folksy Tom
Friedman and New Age Imperialism
* Government
Without Consent
* The
Desperate State of the Union
* Iraq’s
Election Fiasco
* Boarding
Up the "Window of Opportunity"
* KGB
Chieftain Finds Home at Homeland Security
* Bush’s
Grand Plan: Incite Civil War
* Pink Slips
at CBS